i cant belive that brezze pelt, Loinblaze, Jayfeather and Hollyleaf and kin. this is the best book the Power of three

I hate Hollyleaf! she deserves to die. She had made Leafpool lost it's title for a medecine cat and she wanted to kill her own mother! But I think Leafpool should have never have kits when she is a medecine cat. Brambleclaw does not deserves to be unhappy. This book is excellent.

hollyleaf is so mean, she wants her own mother to die? i'd kill hollyleaf myself if i were a cat... too bad she didn't die in the rockfall. she deserve to die anyways. she don;t deserve to go to star clan. she's not good enough. Oh yeah,... And holly leaf is actually still alive, which is sad.

I, too, will not miss Hollyleaf. I, too, have found her to be REALLY annoying, from her beginning. I got so tired of her harping on and on about the Warrior Code. Her brothers are capable of much more nuanced thought. Unfortunately, they are just as narrow-minded as HL about the news of their "real" as opposed to "natural" or "birth" parents. It seems the authors had a real opportunity to explore the issue of adoption, and what to tell the children, but they sidestepped it. The brothers two make life really hard on both their birth mother and their adoptive parents who, after all, were just doing what the birth mother asked them to. Also, keeping Brambleclaw in the dark was wrong of both sisters, I think. Personally, I think it's wrong to lie to anyone involved in the birthing and raising of children. And in this clan of beings living so close together, did they really think no one would figure it out? Still, I love the series. This is my biggest complaint so far.

Such a sad ending!!! I can't believe it... :( But a really really really good book! One of my favourite book of the series probably. Really good series. Erin Hunter are really good writers! But really sad ending...

I'm glad Hollyleaf is "dead". She was annoying to the enth degree. Got to love Purdy though! Thank got I can stat teh Fourth Series now! ^.^'

great thanks alot everyone spoiled it for me never looking at comments again AFTER I finish the book -.-

@HollyleafofThunuferClan: Hollyleaf, I am really sorry to say but you are dead and you are not one of the three. Dovewing of ThunderClan is. And why am I talking to a dead cat from StarClan???

c'mon, give Hollyleaf a break! She's just having a fit she's not the third cat in the prophecy or Leafpool's her mother. She's an amazing fighter! You guys know that!

Hollyleaf is so mean and Lionblaze is so strong